Welcome!

Video Authors: Stephen Wong, Ben Bradley

Related Topics: Java, Adobe Flex, AJAX & REA, iPhone, Open Web

Java: Article

Java Updater: Sun and Google Are as Bad as Apple

Viewpoint: If there were ever a reason for a law to be passed, this is it.

Bob Plankers' Blog

The ever-annoying, ever-moronic[*]  Java Updater popped up today and prompted me to update. I indulged it, figuring there was probably some new gaping security hole again.

What did I find as I proceeded? It wanted to install the Google Toolbar. Did I have the Google Toolbar already installed? No. So why is the default action to install it, unless I opt out?

Apple’s taken some heat lately for their decision to push Safari to anybody who runs their Apple Software Update utility. I didn’t want Safari, but unless I opt out of it I’ll get it. Now Sun and Google are doing the same thing with the Google Toolbar. Users know that if they don’t update their software they’ll get hacked, and Sun, Google, and Apple abuse that by pushing unwanted applications (Safari) and spyware (Google Toolbar) to systems that didn’t already have it. It isn’t enough that they allow you to opt-out. They do this knowing that most users aren’t going to opt out, either because they don’t know any better or because they miss the option.

If there was ever a reason for a law to be passed, this is it.

———————-

[*] Ever-moronic because the updater seems to like starting two, three, or four copies of itself, all sitting in my system tray. Maybe they think that I’ll be more inclined to update if the updater takes over the entire bottom of my screen.

More Stories By Bob Plankers

Bob Plankers blogs as The Lone Sysadmin at http://lonesysadmin.net/.

Comments (6) View Comments

Share your thoughts on this story.

Add your comment
You must be signed in to add a comment. Sign-in | Register

In accordance with our Comment Policy, we encourage comments that are on topic, relevant and to-the-point. We will remove comments that include profanity, personal attacks, racial slurs, threats of violence, or other inappropriate material that violates our Terms and Conditions, and will block users who make repeated violations. We ask all readers to expect diversity of opinion and to treat one another with dignity and respect.


Most Recent Comments
Skip 05/23/08 11:35:55 AM EDT

I administer over 300 computers at a school. I need to update Java regularly to keep applications some of our server side applications running. Google toolbar slows many of the dinosaur aged systems I can't afford to replace. Why can't Sun just include a switch to deselect Google when running the executable offline in silent mode. I have not been able to find any way to opt out of the installation when running it from a script.

Chris 05/20/08 05:26:56 PM EDT

Stop your whinning and uncheck it. Better yet totally remove Java from your computer!

darted 04/28/08 09:37:40 AM EDT

Well, as for multiples, sounds like an install problem. I have a machine that I have multiple copies of JDK and JRE installed over time (and some not removed for testing purposes) and only one updater runs.
As for the opt out by default being what SHOULD be required - I agree wholeheartedly.

Sun emp 04/25/08 04:13:57 PM EDT

Even working for Sun.. I totally agree an detest this stupidness

Paul Allen 04/25/08 09:53:43 AM EDT

I hate to say it, but this functionality has been nothing new. This was introduced sometime in the later updates of the 1.5 JRE. This is nothing new for the industry either, install the latest version of flash and you'll find the same thing.

JimBen 04/24/08 09:30:29 PM EDT

I don't care who does it: Microsoft, Sun, Apple, Google, Real, Adobe, Roxio.
Any software company that presumes to install background processes on my machine without explicitly begging for my permission earns my animosity, resentment and cynicism. Bastard coated bastards with bastard filling, they are.
Mozilla, you earn my highest respect and kudos for the class and elegance by which you handle the update process.